Subject: TAB: "September Gurls" (Big Star)
Here's the only Big Star song many people know. The Bangles covered
this on their great _Different_Light_ album (not as good as _All_
_Over_The_Place_, but this isn't the time...), and while the
emphasis of their version seemed to be on the vocals (which is the
reason why Michael Steele is my favorite Bangle, for those of us who
have one), the original just plain focuses on the song, pure and
simple. If you know what that means, let me know. Notes:
1) Both guitars are capoed up 2 frets. Thus, all info is based on
chord shape, not concert pitch. If the TAB says "2," then the note
is played on the 4th fret of the neck, which is the 2nd fret if
the capo is the nut. Make sense? This is standard business that
I'm describing poorly.
2) The rhythm guitar (guitar 1) is very clean and jangly. The lead
guitar (guitar 2) is kinda biting and sharp. I'm not sure how to
get that sound, but if you jangle with both guitars, you'll
probably sound okay. If you want, you can tune down your high E
string to D and let it ring throughout the solo, which sounds
good and only necessitates a few horrendous stretches across the
fingerboard. Do what you want.
3) Kinda like in "The Ballad of El Goodo," the rhythm guitar is
mostly extremely simplistic. I'm not writing most of the rhythm
out in TAB because it would waste space and tell you not much
more than you already know. If you just keep pounding away at
quarter note intervals, you'll sound great. Also assume that if I
don't specify otherwise, guitar 1 is always playing chords at the
aforementioned rhythm. So if you just see a guitar 2 fill, guitar
1 is still going at it unless I've said it isn't. Capice?
4) No backing vocals written here, nohow.
5) As he was the only guitarist in the band at this point, Alex
Chilton played both parts, overdubbing them. This would be hard to
do on stage, so chances are that you'll need 2 guitars. But it
can be done on one guitar, trust me. I think the Bangles did it.
6) The little ghost notes in the intro are basically just there
because that's what should happen when you make the changes. Don't
try to put them there. If you play it right, it should just kinda
happen.
7) The TAB for guitar 2 during the bridge ("When I get home...") is
somewhat of an approximation. There's something more complex than
just palm-muted power chords going on here, but I can't tell what
it is. The single-note lines should be right, though. It looks
scary, but that's only because Chilton hits one or two notes in
the middle of a bend. Listening to the song (never a bad idea
anyway) will show what it is you're shooting for.
8) I'm not sure, but I think Chilton (and bassist Andy Hummel, for
that matter) may have made a mistake in the rhythm part behind the
solo. In the first 2 bars, he plays D D D D | A A G G, when the
rest of the time he plays D D A A | G G G G. Whether it was
intentional or not, it sounds good, anyway, but the fact that the
first 2 bars are different from the pattern set up in the rest of
the solo is perplexing. To me, at least. But it's his song, so he
can do whatever he wants.
9) The Bangles version is almost exactly the same except:
a) The solo is different. The Bangles solo is a lot faster and,
frankly, kinda confusing. I'd like to know it, but not that
badly. The Bangles do something not entirely unlike the BS
solo during their outro. Oh, and they correct the "mistake" I
mentioned in the last note.
b) Lyric changes:
"I was your butch" to "And for so long"
"I loved you, well, never mind" to "I loved you, boy, never
mind" (a small change, but I thought it was a nice touch)
"the time she make things right" to "the time he makes
things right" (obvious, but I'm just pointing it out)
"when she makes love to me" to "when he makes love to me"
(ditto)
c) It sounds like there may only be one guitar in the Bangles
version. Lead and rhythm seem to have been incorporated into
one guitar (I may be wrong, though). Because of this, the
fills are simplified.
d) The Bangles change the complex mixture of chords (A7sus4 and
G - is this a G6add9?) in the bar before the solo to a
straight G chord and add an extra bar of G immediately
afterwards to show off their amazing vocal harmonies before
the solo. Not like Big Star couldn't have done this, but they
just didn't.
e) The Bangles repeat the descending intro bit quietly after the
song has finished.
f) There's lots of keyboard in the Bangles version.
g) The Bangles version is followed by "Angels Don't Fall in
Love," while the Big Star original goes into "Morpha Too."
Kind of a stupid thing to point out, but it alters one's mood
after hearing SG.
Gee, maybe the Bangles version isn't exactly like the Big Star
version...
10) No, I don't know why he spelled it "Gurls" (anyone?). I don't
think it matters.
"September Gurls" (Alex Chilton)
Performed by Big Star
From the album _Radio_City_ (on one outstanding CD with _#1_Record_)
Transcribed without permission by Marc Hirsh, but really, I'm just
trying to help
Notation:
s - sixteenth note
e - eighth note
q - quarter note
h - half note
w - whole note
. - play note for one and a half times the value before it (just like a dot in
standard notation)
^ - ties two note lengths together
NOTE LENGTHS IN CAPITAL LETTERS MEAN REST FOR THAT VALUE OF TIME!
/ - slide up
\ - slide down
h - hammer-on
p - pull-off
CAPO ALL GUITARS UP 2 FRETS
Let ring
(gui[G/D]tar 1)[A/D][G/D][D]
| H q e (e) q e (e) q e (e) q q q q q q q q
|
|(guitar 2)
W W H e e q H e e e e
(guitar 2 out)
(guitar 2)
w H. e e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(guitar 1)
[D] [G]
| q q q q q q q q q q q q q q E s s s s e
|
|(guitar 2) (reverse rake)
Q e q q. e q H e (e) q.^H w
(guitar 2 out)
(guitar 2)
w H. e e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)
q q q. e e q.^h
(guit[A]ar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
| q. e^h q. e^q q
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e
(g[A]uitar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
| e e e q s s s s e e e e q. e e
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e
(guit[A]ar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
| q. e^H q e H s s (e) e q q e e
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e (e) e q H
..
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G][D][A][G]
e e q e e q e e q q q (q.) q q e (e) e q q. e
D A G D A G (guitar 1 plays G
(guitar 2) once and lets ring)
e q e e q e (e) e q q q e q e^H w (w)
(g[D]uitar 2)
q q^q. e e q. s s q.
(g[D]uitar 2)
[E---]
[b-3-]
[G-2-]D-0-
[A---]
[E---] w A
September girls do so much
(g[G]uitar 2)
[E---]b-x-
G-0-
D-0-
A-x-
[E---]
[G](guitar 2)[Em]
w H. e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G][D][G][A]
e e q e e q e e q q q q. q q e (e) e q H
(g[D]uitar 2[A])[G][D][A][G]
e e e q q e (e) H q. e e e q q. (e) q.^q q
(g[D]uitar 2[A])[G][D]
e e q. e e e (e) q q e q (s) s^q.^H
[--]Marc Hirsh (marc@owlnet.rice.edu)
\ /
^ --"It's easy to be nuts. Try being me."
V (_The_Fisher_King_)
Here's the only Big Star song many people know. The Bangles covered
this on their great _Different_Light_ album (not as good as _All_
_Over_The_Place_, but this isn't the time...), and while the
emphasis of their version seemed to be on the vocals (which is the
reason why Michael Steele is my favorite Bangle, for those of us who
have one), the original just plain focuses on the song, pure and
simple. If you know what that means, let me know. Notes:
1) Both guitars are capoed up 2 frets. Thus, all info is based on
chord shape, not concert pitch. If the TAB says "2," then the note
is played on the 4th fret of the neck, which is the 2nd fret if
the capo is the nut. Make sense? This is standard business that
I'm describing poorly.
2) The rhythm guitar (guitar 1) is very clean and jangly. The lead
guitar (guitar 2) is kinda biting and sharp. I'm not sure how to
get that sound, but if you jangle with both guitars, you'll
probably sound okay. If you want, you can tune down your high E
string to D and let it ring throughout the solo, which sounds
good and only necessitates a few horrendous stretches across the
fingerboard. Do what you want.
3) Kinda like in "The Ballad of El Goodo," the rhythm guitar is
mostly extremely simplistic. I'm not writing most of the rhythm
out in TAB because it would waste space and tell you not much
more than you already know. If you just keep pounding away at
quarter note intervals, you'll sound great. Also assume that if I
don't specify otherwise, guitar 1 is always playing chords at the
aforementioned rhythm. So if you just see a guitar 2 fill, guitar
1 is still going at it unless I've said it isn't. Capice?
4) No backing vocals written here, nohow.
5) As he was the only guitarist in the band at this point, Alex
Chilton played both parts, overdubbing them. This would be hard to
do on stage, so chances are that you'll need 2 guitars. But it
can be done on one guitar, trust me. I think the Bangles did it.
6) The little ghost notes in the intro are basically just there
because that's what should happen when you make the changes. Don't
try to put them there. If you play it right, it should just kinda
happen.
7) The TAB for guitar 2 during the bridge ("When I get home...") is
somewhat of an approximation. There's something more complex than
just palm-muted power chords going on here, but I can't tell what
it is. The single-note lines should be right, though. It looks
scary, but that's only because Chilton hits one or two notes in
the middle of a bend. Listening to the song (never a bad idea
anyway) will show what it is you're shooting for.
8) I'm not sure, but I think Chilton (and bassist Andy Hummel, for
that matter) may have made a mistake in the rhythm part behind the
solo. In the first 2 bars, he plays D D D D | A A G G, when the
rest of the time he plays D D A A | G G G G. Whether it was
intentional or not, it sounds good, anyway, but the fact that the
first 2 bars are different from the pattern set up in the rest of
the solo is perplexing. To me, at least. But it's his song, so he
can do whatever he wants.
9) The Bangles version is almost exactly the same except:
a) The solo is different. The Bangles solo is a lot faster and,
frankly, kinda confusing. I'd like to know it, but not that
badly. The Bangles do something not entirely unlike the BS
solo during their outro. Oh, and they correct the "mistake" I
mentioned in the last note.
b) Lyric changes:
"I was your butch" to "And for so long"
"I loved you, well, never mind" to "I loved you, boy, never
mind" (a small change, but I thought it was a nice touch)
"the time she make things right" to "the time he makes
things right" (obvious, but I'm just pointing it out)
"when she makes love to me" to "when he makes love to me"
(ditto)
c) It sounds like there may only be one guitar in the Bangles
version. Lead and rhythm seem to have been incorporated into
one guitar (I may be wrong, though). Because of this, the
fills are simplified.
d) The Bangles change the complex mixture of chords (A7sus4 and
G - is this a G6add9?) in the bar before the solo to a
straight G chord and add an extra bar of G immediately
afterwards to show off their amazing vocal harmonies before
the solo. Not like Big Star couldn't have done this, but they
just didn't.
e) The Bangles repeat the descending intro bit quietly after the
song has finished.
f) There's lots of keyboard in the Bangles version.
g) The Bangles version is followed by "Angels Don't Fall in
Love," while the Big Star original goes into "Morpha Too."
Kind of a stupid thing to point out, but it alters one's mood
after hearing SG.
Gee, maybe the Bangles version isn't exactly like the Big Star
version...
10) No, I don't know why he spelled it "Gurls" (anyone?). I don't
think it matters.
"September Gurls" (Alex Chilton)
Performed by Big Star
From the album _Radio_City_ (on one outstanding CD with _#1_Record_)
Transcribed without permission by Marc Hirsh, but really, I'm just
trying to help
Notation:
s - sixteenth note
e - eighth note
q - quarter note
h - half note
w - whole note
. - play note for one and a half times the value before it (just like a dot in
standard notation)
^ - ties two note lengths together
NOTE LENGTHS IN CAPITAL LETTERS MEAN REST FOR THAT VALUE OF TIME!
/ - slide up
\ - slide down
h - hammer-on
p - pull-off
CAPO ALL GUITARS UP 2 FRETS
Let ring
(gui[G/D]tar 1)[A/D][G/D][D]
E---7-7-(0)-|-5-5-(0)-3-3-(0)-|-2---2-2-------2-|-2-2---2---2-
B---8-8-(0)-|-5-5-(0)-3-3-(0)-|-3---3-3-------3-|-3-3---3---3-
G---7-7-(0)-|-6-6-(0)-4-4-(0)-|-2---2-2-------2-|-2-2---2---2-
D---0-0-----|-0-0-----0-0-----|-0---0-0-------0-|-0-0---0---0-
A-----------|-----------------|-----------------|-------------
E-----------|-----------------|-----------------|-------------
| H q e (e) q e (e) q e (e) q q q q q q q q
|
|(guitar 2)
E-----------|-----------------|-----------------|---------------
B-----------|-----------------|---------------3-|-3-------------
G-----------|-----------------|---------2-(2)h4-|-2-------------
D-----------|-----------------|---(2)h4---------|---(4)\2-0-----
A-----------|-----------------|-----------------|-----------2-0-
E-----------|-----------------|-----------------|---------------
W W H e e q H e e e e
(guitar 2 out)
(guitar 2)
E--------------|---------------
B-x------------|---------------
G-0------------|---------------
D-0------------|-------------2-
A-x------------|---------------
E--------------|---------------
w H. e e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(guitar 1)
[D] [G]
E--2-2-2-2--|-2-2-2-2-|-2-2-2-2-|-5-5---3-3-3-3-3-
B--3-3-3-3--|-3-3-3-3-|-3-3-3-3-|-5-5---3-3-3-3-3-
G--2-2-2-2--|-2-2-2-2-|-2-2-2-2-|-0-0---0-0-0-0-0-
D--0-0-0-0--|-0-0-0-0-|-0-0-0-0-|-0-0---0-0-0-0-0-
A-----------|---------|---------|-----------------
E-----------|---------|---------|-----------------
| q q q q q q q q q q q q q q E s s s s e
|
|(guitar 2) (reverse rake)
E-----------|---------|---------|-5---------------
B-------(3)-|---3-2---|---------|-5---------------
G---2-2--2--|---4-2-2-|-(2)-2---|-0---------------
D---2h4-----|-------4-|-(4)-2---|-0---------------
A-----------|---------|---------|-----------------
E-----------|---------|---------|-----------------
Q e q q. e q H e (e) q.^H w
(guitar 2 out)
(guitar 2)
E------------|---------------
B-x----------|---------------
G-0----------|---------------
D-0----------|-------------2-
A-x----------|---------------
E------------|---------------
w H. e e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)
E--------------|-----------
B-----(h3)-----|---(h3)----
G-2-(2)------2-|-(2)-2-----
D-2-(2)h4----2-|-(2)h4-----
A---------0----|-------2---
E--------------|-----------
q q q. e e q.^h
(guit[A]ar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
E----0-----0----------|--0---3----3--
B----2-----3----------|--2---3----3--
G----2-----0----------|--2---0----0--
D----2-----2----------|--2---2----2--
A----0-----0----------|--0---0----0--
E---------------------|--------------
| q. e^h q. e^q q
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
E---------------------|-----------------
B---------------------|-----------------
G----2-2-2-2--2-2-2-2-|-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-
D----2-2-2-2--2-2-2-2-|-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-
A----0-0-0-0--0-0-0-0-|-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-
E---------------------|-----------------
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e
(g[A]uitar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
E-0-0--------3-3-3-3-3-3-|-0-0---3--3-3-
B-2-2--------3-3-3-3-3-3-|-2-2---3--3-3-
G-2-2--------0-0-0-0-0-0-|-2-2---0--0-0-
D-2-2--------2-2-2-2-2-2-|-2-2---2--2-2-
A-0-0--------0-0-0-0-0-0-|-0-0---0--0-0-
E------------------------|--------------
| e e e q s s s s e e e e q. e e
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
E------------------------|------------------------
B------------------------|------------------------
G-2-2-2------------------|-2-2-2------------------
D-2-2-2-2-4b5-(b)5(r4)-2-|-2-2-2-2-4b5-(b)5(r4)-2-
A-0-0-0------------------|-0-0-0------------------
E------------------------|------------------------
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e
(guit[A]ar 1)[A7sus4][A][A7sus4]
E----0-----0-------------|--0---3-----x-3--|-(3)-3-3-3-3-3-
B----2-----3-------------|--2---3-----x-3--|-(3)-3-3-3-3-3-
G----2-----0-------------|--2---0-----x-0--|-(0)-0-0-0-0-0-
D----2-----2-------------|--2---2-----x-2--|-(2)-2-2-2-2-2-
A----0-----0-------------|--0---0-----x-0--|-(0)-0-0-0-0-0-
E------------------------|-----------------|---------------
| q. e^H q e H s s (e) e q q e e
|
|(guitar 2 - palm muted during chords only)
E------------------------|---------------0-|-(0)-0-0-0-
B------------------------|---------------3-|-(3)-3-3-3-
G-2-2-2------------------|-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-0-|-(0)-0-0-0-
D-2-2-2-2-4b5-(b)5(r4)-2-|-2-2-2-2-2-2-2-0-|-(0)-0-0-0-
A-0-0-0------------------|-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-2-|-(2)-2-2-2-
E------------------------|---------------3-|-(3)-3-3-3-
e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e (e) e q H
..
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G][D][A][G]
E-----------------|------------|--------5----|------5---------
B-8h10-10-8h10-10-|-8h10-7-5-3-|-(3)-3-(3)-3-|-(3)-(3)-3----8-
G-----------------|------------|-------------|-----------0----
D-----------------|------------|-------------|----------------
A-----------------|------------|-------------|----------------
E-----------------|------------|-------------|----------------
e e q e e q e e q q q (q.) q q e (e) e q q. e
D A G D A G (guitar 1 plays G
(guitar 2) once and lets ring)
E------------------|--------------|---------|-0-|-(0)-
B-h10-10-8h10-10-8-|-(8)h10-7-5-3-|-2-3-3---|-3-|-(3)-
G------------------|--------------|---------|-0-|-(0)-
D------------------|--------------|---------|-0-|-(0)-
A------------------|--------------|---------|---|-----
E------------------|--------------|---------|---|-----
e q e e q e (e) e q q q e q e^H w (w)
(g[D]uitar 2)
E----------|-----------------
B-3-3------|--------3--3-3---
G-0h2----2-|----(2)-2--4-2-2-
D-0-0----2-|-(2)h4---------4-
A----------|-----------------
E----------|-----------------
q q^q. e e q. s s q.
(g[D]uitar 2)
[E---]
[b-3-]
[G-2-]D-0-
[A---]
[E---] w A
September girls do so much
(g[G]uitar 2)
[E---]b-x-
G-0-
D-0-
A-x-
[E---]
[G](guitar 2)[Em]
E--------------|---------------
B-3------------|---------------
G-0------------|---------------
D-0------------|-------------2-
A-x------------|---------------
E--------------|---------------
w H. e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G]
E-------------------------|------------
B----------3------3-3-(3)-|---(3)------
G-----2-2-(2)-(2)-2-2--4--|----4---0---
D-(2)h4--------2-------5--|----5---0-2-
A-------------------------|------------
E-------------------------|------------
e e e q e e e e e e q e
(g[D]uitar 2)[A][G][D][G][A]
E-----------------|------------|----5---5----|------5------
B-8h10-10-8h10-10-|-8h10-7-5-3-|-3-(3)-(3)-3-|-(3)-(3)-3---
G-----------------|------------|-------------|-----------0-
D-----------------|------------|-------------|-------------
A-----------------|------------|-------------|-------------
E-----------------|------------|-------------|-------------
e e q e e q e e q q q q. q q e (e) e q H
(g[D]uitar 2[A])[G][D][A][G]
E-------------|----------|-----------|------------
B-3-2-------3-|-(3)-2-3--|-3-2-------|-----3------
G-2-2---2-0-2-|-(2)-2-2--|-2-2---2-0-|-(0)-0----0-
D-------4-0---|----------|-------4-0-|-(0)-0----0-
A-------------|----------|-----------|------------
E-------------|----------|-----------|------------
e e e q q e (e) H q. e e e q q. (e) q.^q q
(g[D]uitar 2[A])[G][D]
E-----------------|------------------|-----10-----
B-8h10-10-8h10-10-|-(10)-10-10-10-10-|-(x)--------
G-----------------|------------------|------------
D-----------------|------------------|------------
A-----------------|------------------|------------
E-----------------|------------------|------------
e e q. e e e (e) q q e q (s) s^q.^H
[--]Marc Hirsh (marc@owlnet.rice.edu)
\ /
^ --"It's easy to be nuts. Try being me."
V (_The_Fisher_King_)
